Singh, Indubala U. (1999). Environmental Education through Video-instructional Package : An Exploration. Unpublished. Ph.D., Education. South Gujarat University, Surat.
Objectives of the Study:This work was taken up with the major objective of exploration into the effectiveness of a new medium of instruction . The major areas of concern had been (I) comprehension , (ii) attention and appeal (iii) fulfillment of objectives . The study was delimited to formal classroom situation .
Six experimental groups , each consisted of 40 students were formulated . In all about 240 students of standard -IX of secondary schools of Gujarati medium participated in the present study .
Video-instructional package consisted of video-film and learner’s handbook developed by the investigator was used for conducting the experiment . For evaluation of the programme a multi-faceted approach was developed and used and a number of evaluative tools were developed which included (I) criterion tests , (II) attention measures , (iii) expert’s judgement and (iv) opinionnaire for the students .
Since the investigation was a developmental cum experimental in nature.The first part consisting of the developmentof Video-instructional Package on ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ and the second part concerned with the experimental tryout of the package and its two components . Pre-test , post-test design was used for conducting the experiment .
For analysis and interpretation of the data both the descriptive and quantitative statistics were used . ‘t’- test , ‘F’- test and analysis of covariance were used for testing the significance of the mean differences . Attention profiles have been developed and presented to discuss attention and appeal areas of concern .
1.The study has resulted in the development of a video instructional package on ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ for creating environmental awareness among school going children of Gujarati medium schools . The developed instructional package consisting of a video-film of forty five minutes and a learner’s hand book of ten pages ( demisize). The content of the package based on the environment -meaning , components and types and four important environmental pollution such as air pollution , water pollution ,soil pollution and noise pollution . The content of each pollution was further divided into meaning -definition , causes ,effect on living beings and remedial measures .2. The developed video-instructional film was found significantly effective in teaching environmental education to the students of standard -IX of Experimental Group - I belonged to Surat -city ( t-value : 34.66 ) The ‘ t ‘ test signifies that the developed video-instructional film was found effective in teaching the topic ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ . Thus , the Video-instructional Film for the students has performed in the way , it was purported to , thereby manifesting its validity .3. Students attentively witnessing the programme ranged between 60 to 100 percent . For most of the time it ocilated around 80 percent . It could be inferred from these data that the video instructional film proved to be effective in motivating the students and sustaining the attention on the part of the programme .4. The ‘ t ‘-value ( 1.61) signifies that the developed video instructional film was found equally effective in teaching the topic ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to boys and girls.5. The ‘ t‘-value (20.47) signifies that the developed Learners’ hand book was found effective in teaching the topic‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ . Thus , the developed learners’ hand book for the school students has performed in the way , it was purported to , thereby manifesting its validity .6. The ‘ t ‘ test signifies that the developed learners’ hand book was found equally effective in teaching the topic‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to the boys and girls of Surat-city .7. The ‘ t ‘ test signifies that the developed video-instructional package was found effective in teaching the topic‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ . Thus , the developed video-instructional package for the school students was found
effective in imparting knowledge related to environmental education .8. Students attentively witnessing the programme ranged between60 to 100 percent . For most of the time it ocilated around 80 percent . It could be inferred from these data that the video instructional package proved to be effective in motivating the students and sustaining the attention on the part of the programme .9. The ‘ t ‘ test signifies that the developed video-instructional package was not found equally effective in teaching the topic‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to boys and girls of standard - IX of Surat city . Boys could learn through this package better than the girls .10. The computed ‘ t ‘ value ( 34.66 ), was found significant at 0.01 level . It indicates that significant improvement has been achieved after the treatment of the Video-instructional film .The ‘ t ‘ test signifies that the developed video-instructional film was found effective in teaching the topic ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ . Thus , the Video-instructional Film for the students has performed in the way , it was purported to , thereby manifesting its validity .11. Students attentively witnessing the programme ranged between60 to 100 percent . For most of the time it ocilated around 80 percent . It could be inferred from these data that the video-instructional package proved to be effective in motivating the students and sustaining the attention on the part of the programme .12. The ‘ t ‘ value (20.47) signifies that the developed Learners’ hand book was found effective in teaching the topic
‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ for the students of Experimental Group - V ( Surat - rural ) . Thus , the developed learners’ hand book for the school students of rural area of Surat has also performed in the way , it was purported to ,thereby manifesting its validity .13. The ‘ t ‘ value (3.09) signifies that the developed learners’ handbook was not found equally effective in teaching the topic ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to boys and girls of Experimental Group - V. It reveals that the girls could learn better than the boys through the learners’ hand book .14. The ‘ t ‘ value (37.87) signifies that the developed video instructional
package was found effective in teaching the topic‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to the students of Experimental Group - VI of Surat -rural . Thus , the developed Video-instructional package was also found effective in imparting knowledge related to ‘Environmental pollution and education’ to the students of standard - IX of Gujarati medium schools belong to the rural area of Surat.15. The ‘ t ‘ value (2.48) signifies that the developed video instructional package was not found equally effective in teaching the topic ‘Environmental Pollution and Education’ to boys and girls of standard - IX of Surat - rural .The result
revealed that the rural boys could learn better through this video-instructional package in comparison to the rural girls .16. The achievements of learners in terms of pre-test scores obtained for the three experimental groups ( I, II & III ) for Surat - city before any treatment was compared and found insignificant .17. The achievements of learners in terms of pre-test scores obtained for the three experimental groups ( IV , V & VI ) for Surat - rural before any treatment were having insignificant differences among their means .18. The gain scores obtained for three experimental groups of Surat - city differ significantly with each other . Further comparison shows that the mean gain score (70.9) of Experimental group -III having the treatment of Video instructional package was greater than the gains of other two groups . The Experimental Group -II having the treatment of Learner’s Hand book was the least in terms of mean gain score (46.3). Whereas , the mean gain score (58.7) of Experimental Group - I having the treatment of Video instructional film was better than the Learner’s Hand book.(46.3).19. The gain scores obtained for three experimental groups of Surat - rural also differ significantly with each other . Further comparison shows that the mean gain score (57.87) of Experimental group -VI having the treatment of Video instructional package was greater than the gains of other two groups. The Experimental Group -V having the treatment of Learner’s Hand book was the least in terms of mean gain score (42.65). Whereas , the mean gain score (47.82) of Experimental Group - IV having the treatment of Video instructional film was better than the Learner’s Hand book.(42.65). Thus , the result found for the students of Surat - city and Surat -rural were similar in terms of the effectiveness of whole package and for its two components .20. On comparision of the gain scores of Group -I (Surat-city) with Group-IV (Surat-rural) having the same treatment of Video instructional film it was found that the learning environmental education through Video-instructional film in the students of Surat - city was significantly better than the students of rural area of Surat .21. On comparision of the gain scores of Group -II (Surat-city)with Group- V (Surat-rural) having the same treatment of Learner’s hand book , it was found that the learning environmental education through Learner’s hand book was equally beneficial for both the groups of students of Surat -city and the students of rural area of Surat .22. On comparision of the gain scores of Group -III (Surat-city) with Group- VI (Surat-rural) having the same treatment of Video instructional Package, it was found that the learning environmental education through Video-instructional package(consisted of video-instructional film & Learner’s hand book) was significantly better for the students of Surat - city in comparison to the students of Surat-rural .23. All educational experts found the selected theme and the sequence of frames very appropriate . Inspite of few limitations the video-instructional package was evaluated by all the experts to be a laudable attempt in presenting environmental education for the students of Gujarati medium .24. The majority of the students found the package knowledgeable ,innovative , systematic and interesting .Most of the students of standard -IX of Surat -city as well as of Surat-rural likedand enjoyed learning through Video-instructional package .They were also ready to use such packages in future for other Subjects , too .
Educational Implications of the Study.
The results of the present study indicates that teacher made video-instructional packages can be used effectively for creating awareness and providing information to school students. Therefore ,such more attempts should be taken for some other important aspects of life as per the needs of the students . It could be used as an instructional system in both formal as well as in non - formal situation. The present study also recommends regarding the organization of the training programmes and work shop for teachers where development of software specially for video package can be learnt and made by the teachers .The study has also implications for administrators, principals, teachers and students for better planning the teaching - learning process .
Keyword(s): Environmental Education, Video-instructional Package, Ecological and Environmental Studies in Education